Evaluation of Stan Grant present China Tonight

Review of Stan Grant show China Tonight

The primary two (of six) episodes embrace explainers on China’s household planning modifications, from the one-child safety of the Nineteen Eighties to the three-child safety of in the meanwhile, and Hong Kong’s shift from British to Chinese language language language Communist Celebration administration.

These sections are principally instructional decisions. To extra invested viewers they will appear too frequent nonetheless Chinese language language language historic earlier purposes have been largely restricted to elective fashions in excessive colleges and solely an estimated 130 Australians of non-Chinese language language language heritage can speak Chinese language language language fluently. The extra background, the higher.

The present is at its finest when it does three deeper dives – into China’s comedy scene, the feminist motion and on-line recreation customized. All of them present new views on rising developments in China. Comic Annie Louey appears to be like on the nuances of why Western jokes fall flat in Chinese language language language comedy, reporter Angharad Yeo explores China’s on-line recreation curfew to cease late-night youngsters fuelling the $32 billion commerce, and Samuel Yang appears to be like on the challenges confronted by youthful feminist organisers all by China.

However in addition to they reveal the restrictions of working a present from the ground attempting in. All by the 2 episodes, just one mainland Chinese language language language voice based totally in China is featured, Maizi Li, a feminist activist whose private social media accounts have been shut down.

In one other case, it’s full of Australian lecturers, Chinese language language language consultants residing abroad or worldwide officers like Wang. It’s an issue all media need to confront now there are not any Australian journalists working for Australian media retailers left in China and most people is more and more extra fearful of chatting with worldwide media, nonetheless one which’s value acknowledging.

The meat of the present for nearer China-watchers is in Grant’s interviews collectively collectively together with his friends. He takes an adversarial, ABC 7.30-style methodology, collaborating throughout the satan’s advocate with Hui (the exiled Hong Kong politician) to ask why Hong Kong ought to have freedoms that absolutely completely different elements of China don’t, whereas urgent Wang on allegations of genocide in Xinjiang.


Wang, a charmer who shouldn’t be from Beijing’s “wolf warrior” faculty of diplomacy, is erudite and worldly. He reduce his tooth in Washington and Brussels. He’s at house on panels and giving speeches nonetheless lots a lot much less so on this Australian vogue of TV interviewing. If Grant can replicate it with some extra heavy hitters out of Beijing or Hong Kong, it ought to make for good TV.

Structurally, the present is attention-grabbing. It goes to broader, lighter areas which can have conventionally achieved present affairs packages earlier than narrowing down. It opens with presenter Yvonne Yong’s “what’s trending?” half on Chinese language language language social media. Racing by way of in mannequin matters on Weibo: the herd of elephants marching all by China, the cult following of TV present Pals, and the infinite stress of faculty entrance exams.


There’s a danger that this technique highlights the “loopy stuff that has occurred in China this week” to seize viewers’ consideration nonetheless it could (for now) be a useful strategy of hooking individuals into some dense supplies.

The present’s most interesting energy is in its differ of reporters. Grant and his producers have given youthful Chinese language language language-Australian journalists and presenters a go, staffing the present with a mannequin new batch of reporters who may very properly be key to Australia understanding China all through the years forward.

Eryk Bagshaw is the North Asia correspondent for The Sydney Morning Herald and The Age.

China Tonight is on Tuesday, ABC Data, 8pm and ABC, 10.30pm

Present hyperlink

You may also like

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *